Naturally we watched it with an eye towards seeing how much everything matched up with Episode III.
The answer is, surprisingly well. And the main reason, I think, can be summarized in two words: Alec Guiness (or, if you prefer three words, Sir Alec Guiness).
Understand, I don’t believe for a second that Lucas had already decided at the time that Leia and Luke were siblings, that Obi Wan was present at their birth. I’m even 50/50 that he’d decided Vader was Luke and Leia’s father, or even Luke’s father.
Most of the “mismatches” are centered around Obi-Wan, and thanks to Guiness’ performance–and I chalk it up to Sir Alec since Lucas is notoriously “not there” for actors–it is VERY easy to read it that he is either lying or playing things very close to the vest. Not only does he greet RD as “my little friend,” but when Luke IS conscious and R2 is beeping at him, Obi Wan fires R2 a look that could be taken, with no difficulty, as “Shut up. You’ve already said too much.” And when he’s explaining bits of his history to Luke, you can see the wheels turning as he’s doing so. He alternates between looks of craftiness and being avuncular. These shadings that Guiness brought to the role left Lucas a ton of leeway in subsequent films.
Not Sir Alec-related, but I’m surprised how much the offhand bit about 3PO getting his memory wiped actually works. Because in episode 4, when Luke is asking him about past encounters with the Empire, 3PO says hesitantly, “We’ve been in several battles…I think.” He sounds confused. If his memories had been wiped, it would make sense that there might be some memory bits still floating around in there–random flashes of images and such–that would cause him to vaguely recall that they’d seen action, but unclear as to the when or where.
And finally, for all those who complained that Anakin seemed to whine way too much…jeez, y’know, Mark Hamill is a dear friend, but sheesh, Luke whined as much as his dad. Listening to Anakin bìŧçh about not being made a Master is evocative of Luke crabbing about not being able to go get power converters. Like father, like son.
PAD
Recent Comments