There is a small brouhaha going around over the tremendous likelihood that the allegedly true story of Frank Hopkins, as depicted in “Hidalgo,” is BS (or, more appropriately, HS). People are shocked–shocked–to discover the historical Hopkins exaggerated his exploits a little. A lot. A whole hëll of a lot.
Well, I took Ariel to see it before I’d heard anything about the brou or the ha ha. And I’m watching thisl film and thinking, “An annual horse race of 3000 miles? The width of the United States? Across scorching desert? On a single horse? No frickin’ way. I’m not even sure there’s that much Arab desert *to* ride across. And by the way, he makes a side trip to rescue an Arab princess? Aw, c’mon.”
I pretty much came to the conclusion while watching that anyone with a couple of brain cells to rub together should think of “Hidalgo” as nothing more than a live action version of those old wild west pulp magazines, and that all claims to the facts being unvarnished–as those magazines likewise claimed–should be given equal credence. Certainly the extreme flexibility of “truth” vis a vis the old west is integrated into the movie’s own story, ranging from the Wild Bill show depicting the slaughter of 300 surrendering Lakota at Wounded Knee as a brave victory for the white man, or an Arab’s perception of the west coming entirely from what he’s read in the greatly exaggerated wild west magazines. A deconstruction of the film’s own veracity, as it were. It’s annoying that Disney didn’t market it that way: It could just be billed as “Based on the tales of Frank Hopkins” and that would be perfectly fair.
Taken on that basis, “Hidalgo” is a rousing film with a nice kid-friendly message about not losing touch with your roots. It features a portrayal of Arabs that depicts them as fairly arrogant at first to the upstart cowboy but, ultimately, is pretty flattering (which is a nice change from the Arabs=terrorists mindset we currently have.) Plus there’s no twenty minute sequence of some poor Jew getting flayed and, hey, y’know, there’s horsies.
PAD





Recent Comments